1. I don't know! About 1 in 10 of trainers answer that they have no idea why the horse returned a positive swab. But not knowing or ignorance is not a relevant defence.
2. I wasn't at the stable and left Joe to get him ready for the races. Joe must have given him the wrong feed. Both the person left in charge of the horse and the trainer are guilty of an offence if the horse is not presented free of a prohibited substance. The trainer can't delegate responsibility of the horse. This case reflects poor communication at the stables either by the trainer in either not giving instructions or else inadequate instructions or by Joe in not understanding the instructions.
3. I gave him what the vet told me to. The horse was OK last time. Some 'positive' swabs found on urine tests are anti-inflammatory drugs used to treat tendon injuries or arthritis pain. The drugs are 'prescription only' treatments and should only be obtained from a veterinarian who has inspected the horse and is aware of its health history. Verbal advice on treatment can be misinterpreted or forgotten. All treatment schedules should be written down by the veterinarian and either attached to the drug container or else kept with the drug container. The veterinarian is responsible for advising on any adverse sequelae (side effects) following treatment. A drug residue which can be detected in a swab is one side effect which a trainer should avoid. Treating a horse using 'left-over' drug from a previous treatment can put the trainer at risk of a 'positive'. The length of time a drug residue remains in a horse's
two 'possibles' would be unusual in a race fit animal and furosemide would be detectable in a swab.
The use of sodium bicarbonate as a feed additive or as a drench can increase blood TCO2. There are other substances which can also increase blood TCO2 which may be accidentally given to a horse by a trainer or other person who is not aware of their effect or else neglects to read the ingredients in a treatment.
These alkalising agents can be found in electrolyte solutions, acidosis treatments, diuretics and urinary alkalisers. They may also be found in human treatments. Common alkalising agents are sodium citrate and sodium succinate.

Makybe Diva certainly had no swabbing worries after the Melbourne Cup

4. It was a herbal/vitamin preparation which I bought over the counter or by mail order. People can mistakenly believe that because herbal or vitamin mixes are 'natural', they should be OK for use in the horse because they are not a 'drug'. Many common drugs originated from 'natural' substances (for example salicylic acid or aspirin from the bark of certain trees). More than 750mcg of salicylic acid in a urine sample is a 'positive' swab. Guarana, the 'yuppies' herbal tablet, is a source of caffeine which is readily detected in a urine sample.
5. I didn't use a milkshake and I have never used one. The horse must have a ‘high bicarb’ because it is a poor traveller/ it came from a hilly area/ it only drinks bore water/it was stirred up in the stables/ it has a bit of a cold . Elevated TCO2 levels in horses can be due to severe respiratory (lung) problems, chronic kidney failure, treatment with the drug furosemide or the administration of an alkalising agent. The first